What would it be like to have a twin that makes choices as different from yours as possible?
This is the premise of this book written by Brit Bennet. In a town that was founded by black people that were striving to be light, two girls were born to the family of one of the founders. Although the founders of this town considered themselves “better” than those with darker skin, it was no real “protection.” A group of white men stormed into their home, pulled their father out by the ankles and hung him for something that he had not done. From then, the fragility of being light was shattered. With the family in financial peril, they were pulled out of school at the age of 16 to work cleaning white people’s home. There they saw first hand how anyone with any color was treated.
The girls run away to New Orleans, looking to build a new life. It was then that they were again confronted with the reality of opportunities that were available to white women that were not available to black woman, even those with light skin. In order to get a job, Stella “passed” as white, making choices to change herself into another person. She selected “white” on the job application, became a secretary, married her boss, and built a new life that she managed to hide from everyone including herself.
Desiree, however, took a different path, marrying a dark black man that ended up beating her. Fleeing her husband’s fists back to Mallard, with her small dark skinned daughter became an outsider in the light black town. As a child, Desiree had been most likely to leave, always restless to be somewhere else. Yet it was Stella that continued to live her lie and not return.
The story traces how each life was different based upon choices that were made when they were young. A choice led Stella to a larger life, yet it was a life of lies. She never felt comfortable being herself until a black woman befriended her and she had to choose all over.
The truth that you can deny your history, but it shapes you anyway, and the acceptance of those that love you for all their flaws and choices, makes this a story of discovering who you are at the core, so you can not only love yourself, but allow yourself to be loved.
Within the story, questions explored include what does it mean to be black? What does it mean to be poor? What is a woman’s place? What makes a man? What does it mean to stay? And ultimately, how do you live with the choices you have made?
Each choses their own path and lives with the consequences.

You must be logged in to post a comment.